Monday, November 17, 2025

The right way to Make the Finest Tomato Sandwich (Actually!) – A Couple Cooks

The basic tomato sandwich is all concerning the glory of juicy, ripe tomatoes! Right here’s our information for find out how to whip up the right mixture of juicy tomatoes, crusty bread, and mayonnaise for a sandwich that’s nostalgic and satisfying.

The right way to Make the Finest Tomato Sandwich (Actually!) – A Couple Cooks

What’s summer season with no nice tomato sandwich? The mix of golden toasty bread, savory tomatoes, and flavorful mayonnaise is actually one in all my favourite methods to take pleasure in this seasonal ingredient.

Alex and I each grew up consuming tomato sandwiches in the summertime. Curiously, my grandpa all the time ate a variation: tomato peanut butter sandwiches (have you ever tried this?). However I like to stay with an herby aioli! Right here is my finest tomato sandwich recipe, stepping it up with basil aioli or tarragon aioli that takes it excessive! It’s one in all my high fast summer season dinner concepts.

Elements you’ll want

The basic tomato sandwich is nothing fancy. However like every recipe, it’s all about high quality of components! Right here’s what you’ll want:

  • Sourdough bread: Highest quality bread makes the perfect tomato sandwich. A basic alternative is white bread, however I like one thing with a little bit extra texture: sourdough bread or a crusty artisan bread like no knead bread or focaccia bread. You can even use a top quality sandwich loaf.
  • Tomatoes: Use solely the perfect ripe tomatoes. Multi-colored heirloom tomatoes add a pleasant contact!
  • Mayonnaise: For a basic tomato sandwich, plain mayonnaise works. Or, use my herb aioli (under) to step it up.
  • Salt and pepper: It’s essential to season the tomatoes earlier than making the sandwich.
Heirloom tomatoes

Step it up with basil or tarragon aioli

This tomato sandwich is scrumptious by itself, but it surely’s even higher with an herb aioli! Aioli is a sauce that comes from the South of France and Spain, often known as allioli or aïoli. Within the US for the reason that 1990’s, it’s turn into widespread to name any flavored mayonnaise aioli.

You may make a easy herb aioli by mincing garlic and both basil or tarragon, then mixing with mayonnaise and a touch of vinegar and mustard. I really like the tarragon aioli model, but it surely’s additionally nice with basil aioli!

Tarragon Aioli

My suggestions for a fantastic tomato sandwich

There are a number of tricks to take your tomato sandwich from good to nice! Listed below are a number of suggestions:

  • Toast the bread first. Toasting the bread in a skillet with olive oil helps to season the bread and make a crunchy, contrasting texture. That is important, in our opinion! (In any other case, the bread is a little bit too squishy.)
  • Use the herb mayo (aioli). Making tarragon aioli or basil aioli actually steps up this sandwich! It’s not required, but it surely provides an excellent quantity of herbaceous taste.
  • Liberally season the tomatoes. All the time season the tomatoes with salt and pepper earlier than including them to a tomato sandwich.

Additionally, keep in mind to all the time eat a tomato sandwich with a serviette! They’re fairly messy—deliberately!

Variations and additions

Personally I really like including to my tomato sandwiches to offer them a little bit extra texture and taste intruige! Listed below are a number of methods to combine up this sandwich:

Storing leftovers

A tomato sandwich is finest eaten instantly after making, for the reason that liquid within the tomatoes causes the bread to turn into soggy. The tarragon aioli lasts as much as 2 weeks refrigerated.

Dietary notes

This tomato sandwich recipe is vegetarian and dairy-free. For vegan, use bought vegan mayonnaise (cashew cream additionally works as a variety). For gluten-free, use gluten-free bread.

Incessantly requested questions

What kind of tomatoes are finest for a tomato sandwich?

Heirloom tomatoes, beefsteak tomatoes, or any ripe, juicy tomato selection will work. Search for tomatoes which can be aromatic, plump, and yield barely to light stress.

Ought to I toast the bread?

Toasting the bread is optionally available however really useful. It provides a refined crunch and helps stop the bread from getting soggy from the tomato juices.

How do I retailer leftover tomato slices?

Retailer any leftover tomato slices in an hermetic container within the fridge for as much as a day or two.


Print

The Finest Tomato Sandwich (Actually!)

Tomato Sandwich

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

No opinions

The basic tomato sandwich is all concerning the glory of juicy, ripe tomatoes! Right here’s our information for find out how to whip up the right mixture of juicy tomatoes, crusty bread, and flavorful mayonnaise for a sandwich that’s nostalgic and satisfying.

  • Creator: Sonja Overhiser
  • Prep Time: quarter-hour
  • Cook dinner Time: 0 minutes
  • Whole Time: quarter-hour
  • Yield: 2 sandwiches 1x
  • Class: Primary dish
  • Methodology: No Cook dinner
  • Delicacies: American
  • Weight loss program: Vegetarian

For the tomato sandwich

  • 4 slices sourdough bread
  • 2 massive slicing tomatoes
  • ½ cup mayonnaise (or herb aioli; see under)
  • Kosher salt
  • Freshly floor black pepper
  • Olive oil, for toasting

For the basil or tarragon aioli (optionally available)

  • 2 tablespoons finely chopped basil or 1 ½ tablespoons finely chopped tarragon
  • 1 small garlic clove
  • ½ teaspoon white wine vinegar or lemon juice
  • ½ teaspoon yellow mustard (optionally available)
  • ½ cup top quality mayonnaise (vegan if desired)

  1. Make the aioli (optionally available): Mince the garlic as finely as doable, then use the aspect of your knife blade to mash and grind it right into a paste. Whisk collectively the garlic and herbs with the white wine vinegar, yellow mustard, and mayonnaise. (Shops refrigerated for two weeks.)
  2. Toast the sourdough bread: Add a drizzle of olive oil to a forged iron pan or skillet over medium warmth. Add the sourdough bread slices, inside aspect dealing with down. Toast for 1 to 2 minutes till golden brown.
  3. Put together the tomatoes: Slice the tomatoes into ¼-inch thick rounds. Sprinkle either side of the tomato slices with a pinch of kosher salt and freshly floor black pepper.
  4. Assemble the sandwich: Unfold mayonnaise generously on one aspect of every toasted bread slice. Layer the tomato slices evenly on two of the bread slices, making certain they cowl the bread fully. Prime with the remaining slices of bread, mayonnaise aspect down.
  5. Serve: Reduce the sandwiches in half and serve instantly. This sandwich is finest loved recent to savor the juicy tomatoes and crispy bread (don’t thoughts the mess!).

Different tomato recipes to attempt

When it’s tomato season, make all of the tasty tomato recipes! Our favourite methods to make use of tomatoes are in a basic Caprese salad or Greek salad. A tomato pie or tomato galette are additionally enjoyable methods to make use of these seasonal components.

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles