
A query I’ve been getting quite a bit these days: “What occurred to your canine???” I get this query through e-mail, via weblog feedback, on Instagram, Fb and in individual. It’s taken me awhile to place collectively my response as a result of it’s a painful one. However at the moment, I’m able to share.
The Tail of Genevieve (aka Gigi) the Hound
Gigi confirmed up emaciated and lined in scratches in our mates’ yard in late September. They (and we) tried to find her proprietor, however she got here with no tags and nobody responded to our ads together with her picture. We took her to the vet to scan her for a microchip and he or she didn’t have one. Our idea is that she was a bear searching canine who received misplaced from her pack and couldn’t discover her means again to them. Our mates saved her at their dwelling for a number of days after which deliberate to take her to a shelter as they have already got a canine and might’t hold a second. We had an opportunity to fulfill Gigi and spend time together with her and we knew we couldn’t let her go to a shelter. So, we introduced her dwelling! She joined our household on October 3, 2022.
Our mates named her Gigi (for good woman) and all of us liked her–the children particularly. She was an ideal canine who liked climbing, didn’t bark and (largely) adopted instructions. Nevertheless: she couldn’t be left dwelling alone. In any respect.
The Can’t-Be-Left-Alone Saga
We crate educated Gigi (as we’d achieved with our earlier canine) and he or she liked her crate. She’d elect to go in there whereas we have been dwelling, would fortunately nap within the crate, slept in there each evening and utilized it to keep away from our kids’s fixed consideration. We assumed this crate coaching would additionally work once we left the home, because it had with our earlier canine. It didn’t.
Poor Gigi had a panic assault each time we left the home, irrespective of how lengthy we have been gone.
1) We figured there should be a behavioral treatment so we sought out a canine coach who gave us a routine to observe.

Amongst different issues, this entailed leaving the home for temporary intervals (~30 seconds to begin) and returning to reward her if she was quiet. Nevertheless, we have been by no means in a position to work as much as an absence of longer than 5 minutes earlier than Gigi started to panic.
We labored with the coach in individual and he or she was flummoxed by Gigi’s panic response to our absence since she was such a relaxed, well-adjusted canine round folks.
2) Then, we figured there should be a technological resolution.
We put in a digicam in order that we might observe her habits within the crate and report again to the canine coach. This didn’t assist. So, the coach urged a camera-treat-dispenser combo thingy, which does precisely what it feels like: you observe the canine via the digicam and remotely dispense a deal with into the crate if the canine is being calm. This didn’t assist.
3) Lastly, we assumed there’d be a medical resolution.
And so started the numerous, many vet visits. We’d already achieved all the behavioral modifications/coaching the vet really useful and so, they prescribed a gentle anti-anxiety remedy. That didn’t work. The vet subsequent prescribed a gentle sedative. Additionally ineffective. Subsequent up was a gentle tranquilizer. And on and on… all to no impact.
Right here’s the complete listing of strategies we tried (that I can keep in mind):
Finally, none of this labored and we couldn’t go away her dwelling alone for any time period. Ever. If we did, Gigi would have a panic assault and poop and pee within the crate and tempo endlessly in circles. This occurred each single time we left the home for longer than 5 minutes.
I washed each canine and crate extra instances than I can rely.
We realized that, as an energetic household with little youngsters, it’s not tenable for one grownup to at all times keep dwelling with the canine. It’s additionally not potential for us to take a canine with us in all places we go. Recognizing that we couldn’t reside this fashion–with one grownup at all times staying dwelling OR the information that we’d return dwelling to a panicked, poop-covered canine–we needed to give Gigi up.
Giving Gigi Up

After 4 months of making an attempt to assist Gigi study to remain dwelling alone, we acknowledged that we merely couldn’t hold her. We have been heartbroken, however didn’t see another choice. I situated a foster-based rescue group that had an area for Gigi and, after an preliminary go to, they accepted her. What they found is that she does advantageous alone in a home IF there are different canines current. They confirmed that she can’t ever be left alone, however that so long as she has a pack–both human or canine–she’s advantageous.
The rescue group–and we–share the idea that Gigi was initially a bear searching canine, which implies she doubtless at all times lived with a whole lot of different canines. They report that Gigi is now adopted and doing simply advantageous in her new household with many different canines. It’s painful to put in writing about this as a result of we liked Gigi and needed to maintain her.
Nevertheless, I additionally needed to settle for the fact that making a household dynamic the place both: 1) one mum or dad at all times stays dwelling and doesn’t attend occasions with the household; OR 2) the household returns dwelling to an hour+ of labor to wash the canine, calm the canine and wash the crate, isn’t cheap or tenable.
Throughout our time with Gigi, we didn’t go to church as a household, we didn’t go to highschool occasions as a household, we not often skied as a household…. and the listing goes on. We needed to settle for that this isn’t the best way we wish to increase our youngsters and, it was placing a whole lot of stress and strain on us mother and father, which the children observed and have been internalizing.
What I Realized

I discovered quite a bit throughout this temporary and tumultuous Gigi expertise. Mainly, I noticed that we rushed into canine possession. We didn’t totally contemplate the ramifications and we let our hearts get forward of our heads. I nonetheless want we had a canine, however I’m additionally at peace with our lack of canine as a result of proper now, our youngsters are my precedence. It didn’t really feel like the suitable trade-off to at all times go away a mum or dad at dwelling to babysit the canine.
It has taken me fairly awhile to put in writing about this as a result of I really feel like a failure of a canine mum or dad.
I’m comforted by the information that when Gigi got here to us, she was malnourished and had been dwelling tough within the woods for who is aware of how lengthy. We gave her a number of meals, love and a heat mattress. And we received her spayed, all of her photographs, and adopted into one other loving household (with different canines!). Once I remind myself of that perspective, I don’t really feel so dangerous. However when the children point out how a lot they miss Gigi, I really feel a little bit stab in my coronary heart.
The Prices
I want we might’ve made it work with Gigi and, I’ll inform you, we spent over $2,000 making an attempt to make it so. $2,373.25 to be actual. I tallied up our Gigi prices, simply out of curiosity and right here’s what I got here up with:
| Merchandise | Quantity | Notes |
| Spaying + foster and adoption prices | $600.00 | We determined to pay the foster group who took Gigi for his or her prices associated to fostering, adopting and spaying. |
| First vet go to, vaccinations, checks, de-worming, microchipping | $497.78 | Since she’d been within the woods alone for an indeterminate period of time, she wanted intensive vaccinations, testing and medicines to de-worm, and so on. |
| Vet go to and medicines | $227.60 | |
| Vet go to and medicines | $186.60 | |
| Meals, beds, treats, toys | $183.98 | |
| Canine coach | $150.00 | Classes with the canine coach |
| Meals | $101.67 | |
| Meals, treats and toys for Christmas | $101.27 | |
| Digicam & distant deal with dispenser | $99.99 | The mixture digicam and distant deal with dispenser, which we utilized in an try and reward her when she was calm within the crate (affiliate hyperlink). |
| Canine snow booties | $37.40 | |
| 2 XL canine Kongs | $35.93 | Two of those extra-large kongs in an try and hold her calm whereas dwelling alone in her crate (affiliate hyperlink). |
| Christmas stocking for Gigi | $35.00 | |
| Excessive-visibility orange vest for climbing | $33.25 | |
| Digicam to watch crate | $28.78 | We received this digicam to watch her crate earlier than we purchased the digicam/deal with dispenser combo factor (affiliate hyperlink). |
| Treatment | $25.00 | |
| Treatment | $16.00 | |
| City Canine License | $13.00 | |
| TOTAL: | $2,373.25 |
I’m grateful we had the monetary capability to sink this a lot cash into making an attempt to maintain Gigi and I don’t remorse spending it as a result of it was in service of our determined try and have a candy household canine. However, it’s an eye-opener to the potential surprising prices of pet possession.

Our earlier canine–Gracie the greyhound–was low-cost by comparability. She price us ~$930 yearly versus the $2,373 we spent on Gigi throughout her 4 months with us. Pets are quite a bit like youngsters in that respect: you already know they’re going to price you, however you by no means know precisely how a lot it’ll be.
This isn’t a cautionary story to by no means undertake a pet, however moderately, an illumination of the potential prices of welcoming an animal into your life. I feel pets ship an outsized return on funding via love, companionship and normal cute antics, however its salient to do not forget that they’re an expense. A major one in some instances.
Will You Get One other Canine?
Not proper now. Truthfully, we’re nonetheless fairly heartbroken over Gigi and never able to go down the canine highway once more. All 4 of us love canines (effectively, Littlewoods stays considerably on the fence), but it surely simply doesn’t really feel sensible for our energetic life-style. Now that our youngsters are older (ages 5 and seven) and the pandemic is in remission, we will really go locations as a household! Pre-pandemic, our youngsters have been infants, then Covid took over, so now it lastly looks like we will do household excursions. We go on day-trips to museums, parks, seashores and extra. We’ve gone snowboarding for a full day as a household and brought the children out to eating places as a deal with. We are able to spend as a lot time exterior in our woods as we would like with out timing our entrances and exits to the home to make sure the canine is okay.
Proper now, I’m savoring this stage of life the place our youngsters nonetheless WANT to hang around with us and discover all the things we do FASCINATING. I wish to feed their curiosity and expose them to arts, tradition, meals! I need the liberty–monetary and in any other case–to do this to the fullest. In mild of this articulation of our priorities and values, we’ve determined to carry off on pets for the foreseeable future.
Canine-sitting = The Excellent Half-Time Pet Answer

To assuage the dog-sized gap in our hearts, we dog-sit for our mates’ canines after they exit of city! Most of our mates have canines, so that is excellent. The children ADORE when a canine comes to remain and it’s an exquisite few days of getting a canine. Then the canine goes dwelling. That is nice by me! I joke that I’m a canine aunt: I get the canine for a bit, spoil it actual dangerous, then ship it dwelling. Additionally, I don’t must pay for the canine. That is actually figuring out for me…. ;).
Conclusion
I don’t have a neat little bow to placed on this story. I simply supply a mirrored image on the truth that typically issues don’t go to plan. Typically you spend a ton of time and money on a canine who can’t stick with your loved ones. Typically you break your youngsters’ hearts. This entire expertise is a reminder to me that I’m not in management. I’m embarrassed and ashamed that we couldn’t work out a option to hold Gigi, however I’m additionally at peace with our choice as a result of I do know it was the very best for our household.
Fast Facet observe on the Current Vermont Floods
We’re okay! Thanks to everybody who reached out to test on us and supply help! You all are very type. I’ll put a full replace in my subsequent Month-to-month Expense Report, however the quick model is that, whereas our city was hit onerous, our home stayed mercifully dry. Our quarter-mile lengthy driveway, nonetheless, was largely eaten by the torrential rain… once more, we’re advantageous, however speak about one other surprising expense! Extra quickly.
